| 1989-90 | Bo Kimble (Men's Basketball - Consensus Second-Team) |
| | Hank Gathers (Men's Basketball - Consensus Second-Team) |
| 1990-91 | Kerry House (Women's Volleyball - Volleyball Magazine Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 1995-96 | Julie Greer (Women's Volleyball - Volleyball Magazine Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 1996-97 | Kim Blankinship (Women's Volleyball - Volleyball Magazine Third-Team) |
| | Tracy Holman (Women's Volleyball - Volleyball Magazine Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 1997-98 | Sarah Noriega (Women's Volleyball - AVCA First-Team) |
| | Reid Priddy (Men's Volleyball - AVCA Second-Team) |
| | Robert Schildts (Men's Vollyeball - Volleyball Mag Third-Team) |
| | Scott Walter (BASE - Collegiate Baseball Freshman First-Team & Baseball America Freshman Honorable Mention) |
| | Michael Schultz (Baseball - Collegiate Baseball Freshman First-Team) |
| | Ryan Beaver (Baseball - Collegiate Baseball Freshman Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 1998-99 | Reid Priddy (Men's Volleyball - AVCA Second-Team) |
| | Billy Traber (Baseball - NCBWA Honorable Mention) |
| | Curt Fiore (Baseball - NCBWA Third-Team) |
| |
| 1999-00 | Sarah McFarland (Women's Volleyball - AVCA Second-Team) |
| | Tracy Sharp (Women's Soccer - College Soccer News Honorable Mention) |
| | Reid Priddy (Men's Volleyball - AVCA First-Team) |
| | Scott Walter (BASE - Collegiate Baseball & Baseball America Third-Team, Sporting News Second-Team) |
| | Billy Traber (BASE - Collegiate Baseball Second Team, Baseball America Third-Team) |
| |
| 2000-01 | Sarah McFarland (Women's Volleyball - AVCA First-Team) |
| | Kevin Witt (Men's Water Polo - USWP Third-Team) |
| | Lucy Windes (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Kevin Witt (Men's Water Polo - USWP Second-Team) |
| | |
| 2001-02 | Kevin Paulsen (Men's Water Polo - USWP Honorable Mention) |
| | Stephen Lipinski (Men's Water Polo - USWP Honorable Mention) |
| | Devon Courtney (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Lucy Windes (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Teresa Guidi (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Sean Smith (Baseball - Collegiate Baseball Freshman First-Team) |
| | Joe Frazee (Baseball - Collegiage Baseball Freshman Honorable Mention) |
| | |
| 2002-03 | Andres Murriagui (Men's Soccer - NSCAA/Adidas First-Team) |
| | Arturo Torres (Men's Soccer - NSCAA/Adidas Third-Team) |
| | Jeff Kovar (Men's Soccer - CoSIDA Academic First-Team) |
| | Kevin Witt (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Teresa Guidi (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Rachel Riddell (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Katie Hicks (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 2003-04 | Kelli Nerison (Volleyball - AVCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Kevin Novak (Men's Soccer - SoccerTimes.com Honorable Mention) |
| | Michael Erush (Men's Soccer - Jewish Sports Review First-Team) |
| | Endre Rex-Kiss (Men's Water Polo - USWP Second-Team) |
| | Teresa Guidi (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA First-Team) |
| | Devon Wright (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Stacia Peterson (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Billy Lockin (Baseball - Jewish Sports Review First-Team) |
| |
| 2004-05 | Matt Kovar (Men's Soccer - NSCAA Third-Team) |
| | Diego Barrera (Men's Soccer - NSCAA Freshman Third-Team) |
| | Endre Rex-Kiss (Men's Water Polo - USWPA Second Team) |
| | Kelli Nerison (Women's Volleyball - AVCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Stacia Peterson (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second Team) |
| | Rachel Riddell (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Vanessa Glendenning (Women's Crew - CRCA Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 2005-06 | Endre Rex-Kiss (Men's Water Polo - USWPA Second-Team) |
| | Ian Elliott (Men's Water Polo - USWPA Honorable Mention) |
| | Brian McShane(Men's Water Polo - USWPA Honorable Mention) |
| | Christine Robinson (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Third Team) |
| | Katie Hicks (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Liz Stewart (Women's Rowing - CRCA Second-Team) |
| | Brian Locke (Men's Golf - GCAA Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 2006-07 | Kim Feeney (Women's Soccer - Soccer Buzz Freshman) |
| | Amanda Lernor (Women's Soccer - Jewish Sports Review First-Team) |
| | Ian Elliott (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Brian McShane (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Stacia Peterson (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Stacia Peterson (Women's Water Polo - CoSIDA Academic Third-Team) |
| | Brian Locke (Men's Golf - GCAA Third-Team) |
| | Laura Mickelson (Track/Cross Country - CoSIDA Academic Second-Team) |
| | Angelo Songco (Baseball - Ping!Baseball/Louisville Slugger Freshman) |
| |
| 2007-08 | Tibor Forai (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Andy Stevens (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Mark Milovic (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Nicole Hughes (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Alex Wike (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| |
| 2008-09 | Tibor Forai (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Andy Stevens (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Third-Team) |
| | Tim Hummel (Men's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Amanda Lernor (Women's Soccer - Jewish Review First-Team) |
| | Nicole Hughes (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Second-Team) |
| | Anne Scott (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Diana Romero (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
| | Casey Flacks (Women's Water Polo - AWPCA Honorable Mention) |
